Monday, August 13, 2018

"What are the odds?" That There is a Doctor on My Flight

"I am serious. And don't call me Shirley." Unless you have someone like Leslie Nielsen on board, the question "is there a doctor on the plane?" isn't one you generally want to hear. Apparently, airlines don't really want the answer to be yes. But what are the chances that there is a doctor on board your flight, should there be a medical emergency in the air?

The answer entirely comes down to the size of the plane you're flying on, assuming that doctors on airplanes show up as frequently as they do in the general population in the U.S. (295 per 100,000 people). The larger the plane, the more likely it is that at least one of the other passengers is a physician.

I assumed that you're not traveling alone, but with 1 other person (and they are not a doctor). That leaves n - 2 other people to draw a doctor from, where n is the number of people on the plane. For simplicity, I also assumed the plane is full (which is often the case), so all I had to source was the number of seats on different airplane models, which I retrieved from SeatGuru. I then filtered on the largest domestic airlines, and threw in Spirit for good measure (although you might not make it to your destination if you fly that airline, regardless of whether there's a doctor on your flight).

Take the largest airplane model/seat configuration in my dataset, the Boeing 777-300ER (77W) flown by United Airlines. There are 366 seats on the plane, leaving 364 passengers that could be doctors. The probability the first person is a doctor is 0.295%, so the probability they are NOT a doctor is 99.71%. The same goes for the second person. And the next. And so on, or 0.9971^364 = 34.12%. This is the probability that ALL other people on the flight are NOT doctors. So the probability at least one of them IS a doctor is 1 - .3412 = 65.88%.

You would need at least 237 seats on the plane to have greater than a 50/50 chance of having a doctor on board.

American, Delta, and United crowd the top of this list, but they also make up most of the bottom too, as their size of aircraft vary widely. Meanwhile JetBlue, Southwest, and Spirit all show up lower, but they have far less variance in the sizes of the planes they fly.


AirlineAirplane Model# in Airplane# LeftProbKey
UnitedBoeing 777-300ER (77W)36636465.88%American
UnitedBoeing 777-200 (772) V436436265.68%Delta
AmericanBoeing 777-300ER (77W)30830659.51%JetBlue
DeltaAirbus A350-900 (359)30630459.27%Southwest
DeltaAirbus A330-300 (333)29329157.67%Spirit
DeltaBoeing 777-200ER/LR (77L)29128957.42%United
AmericanAirbus A330-300 (333)29128957.42%
AmericanBoeing 787-9 (789)28528356.66%
AmericanBoeing 777-200 (777) V227327155.10%
UnitedBoeing 777-200 (772) V3 Two Class Intl26726554.29%
UnitedBoeing 777-200 (772) V2 Three Class Intl26125953.47%
DeltaBoeing 767-300 (76P/76Q)26125953.47%
AmericanBoeing 777-200 (777) V126025853.34%
UnitedBoeing 777-200 (772) V1 Three Class Intl25825653.06%
UnitedBoeing 787-9 (789)25225052.22%
AmericanAirbus A330-200 (332)24724551.51%
DeltaBoeing 767-400ER (76D)24624451.37%
UnitedBoeing 767-400ER (764) Intl24224050.79%
DeltaAirbus A330-200 (332)23423249.61%
DeltaBoeing 757-300 (75Y)23423249.61%
SpiritAirbus A321 (321) V222822648.71%
DeltaBoeing 767-300ER (76H/76Z)22622448.41%
DeltaBoeing 767-300ER (76Z) V222622448.41%
AmericanBoeing 787-8 (788)22622448.41%
UnitedBoeing 787-8 (788)21921747.33%
SpiritAirbus A321 (321) V121821647.17%
UnitedBoeing 767-300ER (76L) Two Class21421246.54%
UnitedBoeing 757-300 (753) V1/V221321146.39%
DeltaBoeing 767-300ER (76L)21120946.07%
AmericanBoeing 767-300 (763)20920745.75%
DeltaBoeing 767-300ER (76T/76W)20820645.59%
JetBlueAirbus A321 (321) V220019844.29%
DeltaBoeing 757-200 (75D)19919744.12%
DeltaBoeing 757-200 (75P)19319143.12%
DeltaAirbus A321 (321)19219042.95%
AmericanBoeing 757-200 (752) Domestic V218818642.28%
AmericanAirbus A321 (321) V318718542.11%
SpiritAirbus A320 (320) V218218041.24%
AmericanAirbus A321 (321) V218117941.07%
DeltaBoeing 737-900ER (739)18017840.90%
DeltaBoeing 757-200 (757)18017840.90%
UnitedBoeing 737 MAX 917917740.72%
UnitedBoeing 737-900 (739) V317917740.72%
UnitedBoeing 737-900 (739) V417917740.72%
SpiritAirbus A320 (320) V117817640.55%
UnitedBoeing 767-300ER (76L) Three Class17717540.37%
AmericanBoeing 757-200 (752) International17617440.19%
SouthwestBoeing 737 MAX 8 (7M8)17517340.02%
SouthwestBoeing 737-800 (738)17517340.02%
AmericanBoeing 737 MAX 8 (7M8)17217039.48%
UnitedBoeing 757-200 (752) V1 Intl16916738.94%
DeltaBoeing 757-200 (75G)16916738.94%
DeltaBoeing 757-200 (75S)16816638.76%
UnitedBoeing 737-900 (739) V1/V216716538.58%
UnitedBoeing 737-800 (738) V216616438.40%
UnitedBoeing 737-800 (738) V316616438.40%
UnitedBoeing 737-800 (738) V416616438.40%
DeltaAirbus A320 (320/32K) V216015837.30%
DeltaBoeing 737-800 (73H)16015837.30%
AmericanBoeing 737-800 (738)16015837.30%
JetBlueAirbus A321 (321) Transcon15915737.11%
DeltaMcDonnell Douglas MD-90 (M90)15815636.93%
UnitedBoeing 737-800 (738) V115415236.18%
UnitedAirbus A320 (320)15014835.42%
DeltaAirbus A320 (320/32R) V115014835.42%
AmericanAirbus A320 (320)15014835.42%
JetBlueAirbus A320 (320)15014835.42%
DeltaMcDonnell Douglas MD-88 (M88)14914735.23%
SpiritAirbus A319 (319)14514334.46%
SouthwestBoeing 737-700 (737)14314134.07%
UnitedBoeing 757-200 (752) V2 PS14214033.87%
AmericanMcDonnell Douglas MD-80 (M80)14013833.48%
DeltaAirbus A319 (319) V213213031.89%
UnitedAirbus A319 (319)12812631.08%
AmericanAirbus A319 (319)12812631.08%
UnitedBoeing 737-700 (737) V312612430.67%
UnitedBoeing 737-700 (737) Micronesia12412230.26%
DeltaBoeing 737-700 (73W)12412230.26%
UnitedBoeing 737-700 (737) Domestic11811629.02%
DeltaBoeing 717-200 (717)11010827.32%
AmericanAirbus A321 (32B) Transcon10210025.58%
JetBlueEmbraer E-190 (E90)1009825.14%
AmericanEmbraer ERJ-190 (E90)999724.92%
AmericanEmbraer ERJ-175 (E75)807820.58%
AmericanBombardier CRJ-900 (CR9) V2797720.35%
UnitedEmbraer EMB 175767419.64%
DeltaEmbraer E-175 (E75)767419.64%
DeltaBombardier CRJ-900 (CR9)767419.64%
AmericanEmbraer ERJ-175 (E75) V1767419.64%
AmericanBombardier CRJ-900 (CR9) V1767419.64%
AmericanBombardier CRJ-900 (CR9) V3767419.64%
UnitedBombardier Q400 V2747219.16%
UnitedBombardier Q400 V1716918.44%
UnitedEmbraer EMB 170706818.20%
UnitedBombardier CRJ-700 V2706818.20%
DeltaBombardier CRJ-700 (CR7) V2706818.20%
AmericanBombardier CRJ-700 (CR7) V2706818.20%
DeltaEmbraer E-170 (E70)696717.96%
DeltaBombardier CRJ-700 (CR7) V3696717.96%
UnitedBombardier CRJ-700 V1666417.23%
UnitedBombardier CRJ-700 V3666417.23%
DeltaBombardier CRJ-700 (CR7) V1656316.98%
AmericanBombardier CRJ-700 (CR7) V1636116.49%
UnitedBombardier CRJ-200 V1504813.22%
UnitedBombardier CRJ-200 V2504813.22%
UnitedEmbraer ERJ-145 V1504813.22%
UnitedEmbraer ERJ-145 V2504813.22%
UnitedBombardier Q300504813.22%
DeltaBombardier CRJ-100/200504813.22%
AmericanBombardier CRJ-200 (CR2)504813.22%
AmericanEmbraer ERJ-145 (ER4)504813.22%
Americande Havilland Dash 8 (DH3)464412.19%
AmericanEmbraer ERJ-140 (ERD)444211.67%
UnitedEmbraer ERJ-13537359.82%
UnitedBombardier Q20037359.82%
UnitedSaab 340B34329.02%
UnitedEmbraer EMB-120 V130287.94%
UnitedEmbraer EMB-120 V230287.94%

No comments:

Post a Comment